STRAWBERRY FILEDS FOREVER: USA’s MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR TRACK 8 – UNFOLDING ITS INCREDIBLE RECORDING PROCESS.

The first recordings of SFF took place between September 26th and November 6th, 1966, while John was filming the movie “How I Won The War” in Almeria, Spain. After his return home, he continued a series of demo recordings at his Kenwood residence to nail down the arrangement of the tune. These recordings include single guitar demos and even attempts at overdubbing other instruments himself (guitars and then keyboards) and double-tracking his vocals. You can find a sample of these Kenwood recordings included on the 1996 released compilation album “Anthology 2,” as well as on the 2006 released album “Love,” which some say resembles Bob Dylan's song “It's All Over Now, Baby Blue,”

Having finalized the arrangement, John debuted the song in EMI Studio Two on November 24th, 1966, just over five months since the group's last recording session. The session began at 7 pm, but since they had hardly been in each other’s' company as a foursome for months, a lax atmosphere ensued with many conversations taking up a good portion of the time.

As explained in his book “Here, There And Everywhere,” engineer Geoff Emerick relates many of the details. “It had been five months since I'd last seen the group, but it might as well have been five years. For one thing, they all looked so different. Garbed in colorful clothes and sporting trendy mustaches – George Harrison even had a beard – they were utterly hip, the epitome of swinging London circa 1966...John was the one who had changed the most: having shed the excess weight he'd put on during the 'Revolver' sessions, he was trim, almost gaunt, and he was wearing granny glasses instead of the thick horn-rimmed National Health spectacles I was used to seeing. He also had very short, distinctly non-Beatleish hair.”

“It was our first night back in the studio, and we were huddled around the mixing console, discussing how we wanted to approach the new album...John Lennon was even more agitated than usual. 'Look,' he said to George Martin, 'it's really quite simple. We're fed up with making soft music for soft people, and we're fed up with playing for them, too. But it's given us a fresh start, don't you see?' From the expression on his face, it was clear that George Martin didn't see. 'We can't hear ourselves onstage anymore for all the screaming,' Paul interjected earnestly, 'so what's the point? We did try performing some songs off the last album, but there are so many complicated overdubs we can't do them justice. Now we can record anything we want, and it won't matter. And what we want is to raise the bar a notch, to make our best album ever.'...Lennon persisted, talking rapid-fire – a sure sign that he was starting to get annoyed. 'What we're saying is, if we don't have to tour, then we can record music that we won't ever have to play live, and that means we can create something that's never been heard before: a new kind of record with new kinds of sounds.'”

“Finally, George Martin called an end to the informal conference. 'Right, then, let's get to work. What have you got for me?' Paul started to say something, but before he could answer, John, shouted out, 'I've got a good one, for a starter!' John could talk over most anyone if he wanted to, and he was never shy about jumping the queue; in fact, the first session for almost every Beatles album was devoted to recording one of his songs. A half smile played across Paul's face as he shrugged his shoulders, backing down gracefully.”

Geoff Emerick continues, “Phil McDonald (2nd engineer) and I strained to hear what was going on downstairs...Down in the studio, George Martin was perched, as usual, on his high stool, positioned in the midst of the four Beatles...John was standing directly in front of him, playing an acoustic guitar and singing softly. Because he wasn't close to any of the microphones we had arranged around the room, I had to push the faders up quite high to hear him. From the very first note, it was obvious that this new Lennon song was a masterpiece. He had created a gentle, almost mystical tribute to some mysterious place, a place he called 'Strawberry Fields.' I had no idea what the lyric was about, but the words were compelling, like abstract poetry, and there was something magical in the spooky, detached timbre of John's voice.”

“When he finished, there was a moment of stunned silence, broken by Paul, who in a quiet, respectful tone said simply, 'That is absolutely brilliant.' Most of the time when Lennon played one of his songs through for the first time on acoustic guitar, we'd all think, 'Wow, that's great,' but this song was clearly something special. 'I've brought a demo tape of the song with me, too,' John said, offering to play it, but everyone agreed there was no need – they wanted to get straight into recording. The energy in the room was staggering: it was almost as if the band's creative energies had been bottled up for too long.”

The Beatles then began to put their heads together to create an appropriate arrangement for the song. George Harrison began working out some “long, Hawaiian-style swoops,” as Geoff Emerick called them, that John wanted in strategic places. (You can hear John himself experimenting with this on the demos he made of the song in his Kenwood music room.) A new instrument was brought into the studio on this day by Mal Evans, this being a Mellotron. It was a keyboard John acquired in the summer of 1965 but had brought into the studio for the first time on this day. John described it as “a machine some guy in Britain invented, and it had tape loops on jazz bands, trumpets, flutes and rhythm sections on it.” Geoff Emerick described it as “a cumbersome keyboard in a polished wood cabinet...each key triggered a tape loop of a real instrument playing the equivalent note. There were three sets of tape loops installed, so you could have flutes, strings, or choir at the touch of a button.” 

The model was a “Mellotron Mark II,” as described by Andy Babiuk in his book “Beatles Gear,” he adding that John “finally found time to experiment with the tape-replay instrument as he looked for a way to include its distinctive sounds on his latest composition. Ironically, it was McCartney who played the Mellotron on the recordings.” Geoff Emerick continues: “It was Paul, as usual, who discovered the musical potential instead of just the novelty value...Within a remarkably short time, he'd worked out an arrangement that beautifully complemented Lennon's haunting vocal line.

Emerick recalls that “several hours” were needed for the group to write and rehearse an arrangement for the song, Ringo even “arranging towels over his snare drum and tom-toms in order to give them a distinctive muffled tone.” As for the Mellotron, Paul chose the “brass” setting which he thought would work nicely in the arrangement, which was, according to the book “Beatles Gear,” “a recording of close-miked trumpet, trombone, and saxophone.”

With the tape rolling at “53 cycles per second so that it sounded faster on replay” (according to Mark Lewisohn's book “The Beatles Recording Sessions”), The Beatles recorded their first take of “Strawberry Fields Forever.” The rhythm track consisted of John on rhythm guitar, Paul on Mellotron, George on slide guitar and Ringo playing muffled drums. Overdubs comprised John's stunning lead vocal, which he then double-tracked in spots, and vocal harmonies by John, Paul, and George. (No maracas can be heard on the recording as indicated in the “Recording Sessions” book.)

As gorgeous as this recording was, it was apparent that it could easily be improved upon, especially because of George's jarring slide guitar parts and Paul's Mellotron flubs at the songs' conclusion. The session ended at 2:30 am the following morning with a general idea of what could be done with the song but nothing releasable as of yet. This recording, however, did finally see an official release on the compilation album “Anthology 2," as well as the "Super Deluxe Edition" box set of the "Sgt. Pepper" album,” minus John's double-tracked vocals as well as the harmony vocals. A portion of this recording was also used in the mash-up of the song used on the album “Love,” this time with the harmony vocals and some of John's double-tracked vocals restored.

Four days later, on November 28th, 1966, The Beatles returned to EMI Studio Two at around 7 pm for another attempt at recording “Strawberry Fields Forever.” With the same team of George Martin, Geoff Emerick and Phil McDonald at the controls, they started from scratch, discounting entirely the recording they labored over just a few days before.

“The big break-through that night,” according to Geoff Emerick, “was Paul's coming up with the stunning Mellotron line that opens the song. Paul's inspiration really set the stage.” However, if you observe closely a particular scene in the Beatles movie “The First U.S. Visit,” a film that candidly documents the group in February of 1964, John can be heard playing on a melodeon what uncannily seems to be the introduction to what now became the Mellotron introduction to “Strawberry Fields” as played by Paul. Had this introduction “been in John's head for years,” as insinuated by Bruce Spizer in his book “The Beatles' Story On Capitol Records – Part One,” or was this just an eerie coincidence?  This small segment of the film also shows up in the 2016 Documentary film "Eight Days A Week - The Touring Years.” Look it up – it's worth a listen.

There were also many changes to the arrangement on this day in the studio, including the sequence of the verses and choruses. After the Mellotron introduction, which was now on the "flute" setting, we go straight to the chorus and then to the first two verses in a row. After a repeat of the chorus, the third verse is heard before the chorus repeats one more time. Then they go into an instrumental version of another verse which was intended to be faded out.

Three "takes" were recorded of the rhythm track on this day, numbered two through four. The instrumentation was John on guitar, Paul on Mellotron, Ringo on drums and George on maracas. “Take Two” nearly made it through to the end but was deemed unusable even more so by John coming in late with his guitar parts on many occasions (as well as some McCartney Mellotron flubs). “Take Three” didn't get past the Mellotron introduction as John comes in complaining about it being too “loud.”

“Take Four” made it through to the end of the song and, although still having noticeable flubs by both John and Paul, it proved to be suitable enough for adding overdubs. John added a slightly sped-up lead vocal (which sounded somewhat "dragged out" when played back at regular speed), Paul added bass, and George added his guitar “swoops,” this time in a less abrasive way. This overdubbed “Take Four” was then given three rough mono mixes at the end of the day for acetate cutting purposes. By 1:30 am the next morning, the session was complete and the group left for the night to mull over whether this version was suitable enough to be the finished version. We should remember though, as Mark Lewisohn states in “The Beatles Recording Sessions,” “For the first time there was no real pressure on The Beatles to deliver a product to a preset deadline. They could, and would, work on a song until they and only they were satisfied with it, irrespective of time.” This version, "take four," did eventually get an official release on the "Super Deluxe Edition" of the "Sgt. Pepper" album in 2017.

After a good nights' rest, The Beatles reconvened at EMI Studio Two at 2:30 pm the following day, November 29th, to once again re-record “Strawberry Fields Forever.” George Martin apparently decided to record them rehearsing the song for a while, rewinding the tape periodically to record over these run-thoughts. When it appeared that they were ready to record a proper “take,” George Martin had the tape rewound to record over the rehearsals.

Just after one of the engineers called out “Take Five,” we hear Paul and John still rehearsing their Mellotron and guitar parts. Paul finalizes the melody line he's going to play for the introduction of the song to sound exactly as we're all used to hearing it, this rehearsal being committed to tape at this point. “Take Five” turns out to be only a false start, not getting past the Mellotron introduction. “Take Six” follows very shortly afterward, this amounting to an almost identical rhythm track as performed the day before. It once again consists of John on electric guitar, Paul on Mellotron, Ringo on drums and George on maracas. This “take” made it through to the completion of the song and was deemed “best.” Interestingly, after this “take” wound down, the tape was stopped, revealing rehearsal segments of the song that it had recorded over. We immediately hear the end of a certain rehearsal that humorously went into double-time, sounding like the rhythm track to their song “What Goes On.” After the tape cuts this off, we hear yet another quick snippet of a rehearsal that only lasts a moment or two.

Overdubs then began, John adding his lead vocal and Paul adding bass guitar to “Take Six.” Then, a tape reduction is made to “Take Six,” this becoming “Take Seven,” allowing more tracks on the four-track machine for overdubbing. According to Kevin Howlett's liner notes in the 50th Anniversary release of the "Sgt. Pepper" album, they mixed all the instruments recorded so far onto 'track one' of the new tape and John's vocals onto 'track three.'  Onto 'track two' of the tape was overdubbed what Howlett describes as "mellotron generated guitar and piano sounds," while John double-tracked his vocals on 'track four.'  It appeared that the song was now complete. Therefore, three more mono mixes of the song were made by the engineering team of Martin, Emerick, and McDonald, the third of these mixes being used to cut four acetate discs, one for each of The Beatles. This version of the song appears on the 1996 compilation "Anthology 2" as well as some releases of the 50th Anniversary edition of "Sgt. Pepper.” “All in all, three long sessions were devoted to recording that one track,” remembers Geoff Emerick, “which seemed like a lot at the time. John seemed to be having a lot of trouble making up his mind about how he wanted the song recorded, but...it was deemed finished.” At 8 pm that evening, the session was over.

However, George Martin sensed that John wasn't happy with the song. “Before the very first recording of 'Strawberry Fields Forever,' John stood opposite me in the studio and played me the song on his acoustic guitar,” George Martin recalls. “It was absolutely lovely. Then when we actually taped it with the usual instruments, it began to get heavy. John didn't say anything, but I knew it wasn't what he originally wanted...I metaphorically shrugged my shoulders and said: 'Well, that really wasn't what I'd thought of, but it's O.K.' And off John went”

George Martin's intuitions were correct. “John went away and listened to the lacquers we had made of it and...a week later he came back and said..., 'George, I'm not very happy about that record we just made. It's not exactly what I had in mind when I first wrote it. I'd like to do it again.' But I had to admit, '...I thought it was going to be a little more flowing than it has been,' John said, 'That's the point. I want it a little smoother. Can you do a score for me and we'll do a new record?' So, I said, 'What do you want to use on it then?' And he said, 'Well, strings and a bit of brass.' So I scored it for some cellos and for some trumpets and various things, and we made another record.”

This conversation probably took place exactly “a week later,” December 6th, 1966, during the recording session used to start a new composition entitled “When I'm Sixty-Four.” The conversation, however, was explained somewhat differently by Geoff Emerick. Referring to John's conversation with George Martin, Geoff Emerick depicts John as inarticulately “mumbling, 'I don't know; I just think it should somehow be heavier.' 'Heavier how John?' George asked. 'I dunno, just kind of, y'know...heavier.' Paul did his best to translate John's abstract notion into concrete musical form. Pointing out how well the flute sound on the Mellotron had worked, he suggested that perhaps some outside musicians be brought in, that the song receives a musical score for some orchestral instrumentation. John loved the idea, specifically requesting cellos and trumpets. 'Do a good job, George,' he instructed the somewhat uncertain producer as he departed the control room. 'Just make sure it's heavy.'”

John got his wish two days later, December 8th, 1966, as The Beatles once again re-convened in EMI Studio Two at 7 pm to start yet another version of “Strawberry Fields Forever.” There was an earlier Beatles recording session that day as well, a three-hour session with Paul for him to record vocals onto “When I'm Sixty-Four.” Shortly after that afternoon session wrapped up at 5:30, George Martin and Geoff Emerick left for a prior engagement even though the “Strawberry Fields” session was due to begin.

Geoff Emerick explains: “Unfortunately, on the night that they began doing the remake, George Martin and I were in London's West End, attending the premiere of the new Cliff Richard film 'Finders Keepers.' George was quite adamant that we go, which really annoyed me. I felt our place was with The Beatles, and I felt certain that they were going to be unhappy about us taking time off so early into an album project. In retrospect, I think it may have been a psychological ploy on George's part to show them who was in charge.”

In their absence, however, technical engineer Dave Harries was there to get things going. “Soon after I had lined up the microphones and instruments in the studio that night,” Dave Harries recounts, “The Beatles arrived, hot to record. There was nobody else there but me so I became producer/engineer. We recorded Ringo's cymbals, played them backward, Paul and George were on timps (timpani) and bongos, Mal Evans played tambourine, we overdubbed the guitars (on to "Take 15"), everything. It sounded great. When George and Geoff came back, I scuttled upstairs because I shouldn't really have been recording them.” The guitar phrases, described by Ian MacDonald in his book “Revolution In The Head” as “sitar-like guitar fills in the fade,” were played by Paul. Kevin Howlett's liner notes in the 50th Anniversary release of "Sgt. Pepper" sheds a little more light on the recording session for this day “A newly recorded rhythm track with a performance of drums, cymbal, hi-hat, snare drum, bongos, maracas, and tambourine laid to a mono tape machine."

Geoff Emerick recalls, “It was midnight when we finally returned to the studio, only to find the four Beatles still hard at work with...Dave Harries, who had been recruited to start the session in our absence. In the end, only part of what he recorded ever made its way onto the final release version; George (Martin) and I stayed on until nearly dawn and ended up redoing most of it.”

According to Mark Lewisohn's book “The Beatles Recording Sessions,” this wasn't entirely true. “There was still a very long way to go before 'Strawberry Fields Forever' was ready for record release but Harries' version – or part of it, anyway – was a vital part of that record.” The information shows that three-quarters of “Take 15,” produced by Dave Harries, was used in the mix made on that day. “I am very proud of that,” says Harries, “it was a very good record. Geoff was moaning because there was a lot of top (treble) on the cymbals. I said it was the only time there'd been top on any Beatles records!”

There were a total of 15 “takes” of the song recorded on this day, numbered 9 through 24 (numbers 8 and 19 skipped, probably in error). Nine of these "takes" made it through the entire song, but a decision was made to splice together two incomplete "takes," 15 and 24, to create a suitable rhythm track.

After the editing of “Take 15” and “Take 24” was performed by the engineering team of Martin, Emerick and Phil McDonald, they attempted to remix this into “Take 25,” but because of the lateness of the hour, they decided to wait until the next day. The session finally concluded at 3:40 the following morning.

That next day, December 9th, 1966, starting at 2:30 pm, the same engineering team of Martin, Emerick, and McDonald resumed work on creating “Take 25” from the edited “takes” 15 and 24 of the previous day, resulting in all of the previous day’s work being mixed down to one track of a four-track tape. This left three open tracks for overdubbing.

The book “The Beatles Recording Sessions” explains these overdubs: “Onto track two Ringo added various bits of percussion, including some decidedly heavy drum sounds.” As indicated in the liner notes of the album “Anthology 2,” which included the last minute or so of what they created on this day, such as John Lennon stood nearby a live microphone uttering some nonsensical vocalizing. After some nondescript utterances, he clearly states twice (rolling his “r”s, nonetheless) “Cranberry sauce.” Then, when the percussive rhythm track from the previous day runs out, and Ringo is still performing his “heavy drum sounds,” John exclaims, “All right, calm down, Ringo, the song's over.”

As far as the long-held mysterious meaning about the phrase “Cranberry sauce” that actually made it onto the finished release of the record (heard twice on some foreign pressings), Paul himself puts the rumors to bed. “At the end of 'Strawberry Fields' that wasn't 'I buried Paul,' at all. That was John saying 'Cranberry sauce.' That's John's humor. John would say something totally out of sync, like 'Cranberry sauce.' If you don't realize that John's apt to say 'Cranberry sauce' when he feels like it, then you start to hear a funny little word there, and you think, 'Aha!” For many in late 1969, playing this song at a faster speed revealed John saying “I buried Paul,” which became an “Aha!” moment for the rumor mill who insisted from various clues that the cute Beatle had been deceased since late 1966, or around the time that this song was recorded.

Geoff Emerick goes one further in explaining this mysterious Lennon lyric: “John was actually saying 'cranberry sauce,' not 'I buried Paul,' for the simple reason that we were recording around the time of the Thanksgiving holiday, and just before the take, we had all been chatting about turkey and all the trimmings, and how Americans traditionally ate such a meal at that time of year. That's the way John was – he'd often work little phrases or snatches of conversation about something he had been recently reading or talking about into the music he was recording...I'm sorry to disappoint anyone who ever bought into this rubbish, but Paul was, in fact, very much alive and well, and there was never any kind of plan to fool the public by scattering clues about his supposed demise.”

Also on track two was overdubbed George Harrison playing an instrument not heard on any other Beatles song. The book “Beatles Gear” describes the instrument as a “swaramandala (often misspelled as swordmandel). This Indian/Pakistani instrument is similar to a board zither, usually with about 40 metal strings played with a plectrum or plectrums, and provides something like the sound of a high-pitched harp...the swarmandala is prominently heard just before the start of verse two (1:18) and verse three (2;04), and also at the end of the song (from 3:06 and prominently from 3:15).”

It may be surprising to some that George's contribution to Beatles recordings at this point involved Indian instruments, such as the swaramandala or sitar, whenever he could work it in, even relinquishing the guitar to Paul without much hesitation. “I'd just got back from India, and my heart was still out there,” George related. “I was losing interest in being 'fab' at that point.”

Another quick mono mix was then created because they saw a need to cut some more acetates. Afterwards, another overdub carried on this day, which was the very complicated endeavor of backward recording cymbals. Mark Lewisohn explains in “The Beatles Recording Sessions”: “Rather like the two backward guitar solos in 'I'm Only Sleeping,' the taping of the cymbals was no easy task. The pattern was worked out in the normal manner, but it was then written down in reverse so that when recorded and the tape played backwards, the sounds would fit the bars precisely.” Since all of the overdubs performed on this day occurred in different parts of the song, they all appeared on track two of the tape, leaving tracks three and four available for further overdubs. When this was complete, the session ended at 10 pm, they actually finishing for the day before the next day began.

Nearly a week later, on December 15th, 1966, The Beatles entered EMI Studio Two once again to add more overdubs to this new version of “Strawberry Fields Forever.” The session began at 2:30 pm with the first thing on the agenda being recording the distinctive brass and string score that George Martin had prepared for the song. The trumpets and cellos were recorded onto tracks three and four of the tape, which once again called for another tape reduction to open up more tracks for more overdubs. After all, John had not yet recorded any vocals for this remake of the song. Interestingly, there were some parts of George Martin's score for the end of the song that ended up being dropped at the last minute, these trumpet parts being heard at the conclusion of the mix done on this day.

The existing elements of the song were reduced down to tracks one and two of what now became “Take 26.” Onto track three was recorded an exceptionally fast Lennon vocal, John then double-tracking his vocals during the choruses onto track four. Five mono mixes were then performed by the same engineering team of Martin, Emerick, and McDonald, these mixes numbered 5 through 9, undoubtedly made for acetate cutting purposes. This session ended approximately at midnight.

The final overdubs were added to “Take 26” about a week later, on December 21st, 1966, in EMI Studio Two. While work was done on “When I'm Sixty-Four” early that evening, attention was given to “Strawberry Fields” at 10 pm. Lennon added yet more vocals, this time a harmony to the first line of the final chorus (“Let me take you down...) while McCartney plunked piano chords during the finale of the song.

Another disjointed overdub was also recorded on this day as heard during the songs' closing moments. There are two differing accounts of this overdub, Kevin Howlett, in the "Sgt. Pepper" liner notes explaining it as "George Martin added Mellotron, as did John using the 'Swinging Flutes' setting for the end of the song.” Andy Babiuk's book “Beatles Gear,” however, describes this overdub differently and in more detail, identifying it as “swirling Mellotron. This time McCartney played the...left-hand keyboard, selecting a tape of an entire passage of ensemble flutes. The passage was played in a random, repetitive fashion, without necessarily waiting for the internal tape to return to the start after releasing a key. The result sounds something like looped flutes, but is pure Mellotron.” Funny enough, if it was indeed Paul who performed this Mellotron overdub, considering all the contributions that Paul made to this final version of the song, he never laid down a bass track!

With this complete, the session ended at about 11:45 pm. Upon listening to this completely new remake, which can be heard in its entirety on various editions of the 50th Anniversary release of "Sgt. Pepper," it appears that John got the “heavy” version of “Strawberry Fields Forever” that he asked for. Surely, now he would be happy.

“A few days later he rang me up,” George Martin relates in his book “All You Need Is Ears,” “and said: 'I like that one, I really do. But, you know, the other one's got something, too,'” referring to the newly recorded version of the song in comparison to the earlier version. “'Yes, I know,' I said, 'they're both good. But aren't we starting to split hairs?' Perhaps I shouldn't have used the word 'split,' because John's reply was: 'I like the beginning of the first one, and I like the end of the second one. Why don't we just join them together?' 'Well, there are only two things against it,' I said. 'One is that they're in different keys. The other is that they're in different tempos.' 'Yeah, but you can do something about it, I know. You can fix it, George.'”

Geoff Emerick explains this conversation as, not a phone call between John and George Martin, but as an interchange in the recording studio, him witnessing and participating in the conversation as well. “Lennon continued, 'So what I'd like our young Geoffrey here to do is to join the two bits together...You can do it,' he said simply. With that, he turned and headed out the door. 'What do you think, Geoff?' a deflated George asked me after John had gone. My reply was noncommittal. 'I'm not sure; I guess all we can do is have a go.'”

George Martin continues: “John always left this kind of thing to me. He never professed to know anything about recording. He was the least technical of The Beatles. He had a profound faith in my ability to cope with such problems, a faith which was sometimes misplaced, as I certainly felt it was on this occasion. He had presented me with an almost insuperable task. But I had to have a go.”

December 22nd, 1966, was the day that George Martin and Geoff Emerick had “a go” at accomplishing this immense task. Along with 2nd engineer Phil McDonald, they met in the control room of EMI Studio Two at 7 pm to see what they could do at creating a mono mix with John's stipulations.

Mono mixes for both versions of the song needed to be made first. “Take 7” was the finished master of the slower version, and from it, they created mono remix 10. “Take 26” was the master of the faster version, and from it, they created mono remix 11. Now that's all they had to figure out is how to edit remixes 10 and 11 together efficiently. Since they didn't want to repeat any verses in the finished product, the first step was to delete the second verse of the slower version, which was done just after remix 10 was created. This would bring in the second chorus right after the first verse ended in the slower version. That second verse, containing the lyrics “no one I think is in my tree,” would be heard in the faster version later in the finished song. Now to actually make the crucial edit that combined the two versions.

“I listened to the two versions again,” George Martin relates, “and suddenly realized that with a bit of luck I might get away with it, because, with the way that the keys were arranged, the slower version was a semitone flat compared with, the faster one. I thought: If I can speed up the one, and slow down the other, I can get the pitches the same. And with any luck, the tempos will be sufficiently close not to be noticeable. I did just that, on a variable-control tape machine, selecting precisely the right spot to make the cut, to join them as nearly perfect as possible.”

Geoff Emerick adds: “John's request, on the face of it, appeared completely unfeasible given the technology of the time. Today, a computer can quite easily change the pitch and/or tempo of a recording independently of each other, but all we had at our disposal was a pair of editing scissors, a couple of tape machines, and a varispeed control. The problem was that as soon as you speed up a tape, the pitch also goes up; slowing down a tape has the opposite effect, slowing the tempo, but also lowering the pitch. We had our work cut out for us...After some trial-and-error experimentation, I discovered that by speeding up the playback of the first take and slowing down the playback of the second, I could get them to match in both pitch and tempo.”

“Next, I had to find a suitable edit point,” Emerick continues, “one that wasn't obvious. The idea, after all, was to make the listeners think they heard a complete performance. The one I picked happened to fall almost exactly sixty seconds in, at the beginning of the second chorus, on the word 'going' ('Let me take you down 'cause I'm going to...'). Now it was a matter of figuring out exactly when to alter the playback speeds. George and I decided to allow the second half to play all the way through at the slower speed; doing so gave John's voice a smoky, thick quality that seemed to complement the psychedelic lyric and swirling instrumentation. Things were a bit trickier with the beginning section; it started out at such a perfect, laconic tempo that we didn't want to speed it up all the way through. Luckily, the EMI tape machines were fitted with very fine varispeed controls. With a bit of practice, I was able to gradually increase the speed of the first take and get it to a certain precise point, right up to the moment where we knew we were going to do the edit. The change is so subtle as to be virtually unnoticeable.”

The actual physical splice was of great concern as well. “I found that I couldn't cut the tape at a normal forty-five-degree angle,” Emerick explains, “because the sound just kind of jumped – I was, after all, joining together two totally different performances. As a result, I had to make the cut at a very shallow angle so that it was more like a crossfade than a splice. It took many hours to get everything to work perfectly.”

No Beatles were present while this landmark editing job was being performed but, lo and behold, one did show up moments later. “John popped by to see how we were getting on – I had literally finished the edit just a few moments before he arrived. As we played the results of our labors to John for the first time, he listened carefully, head down, deep in concentration. I made a point of standing in front of the tape machine so that he couldn't see the splice go by. A few seconds after the edit flew past, Lennon lifted his head up, and a grin spread across his face. 'Has it passed yet?' he asked. 'Sure had,' I replied proudly. 'Well, good on yer, Geoffrey!' he said. He absolutely loved what we had done. We played (it) over and over again that night for John, and at the conclusion each time, he'd turn to us and repeat the same three words, eyes wide with excitement: 'Brilliant. Just brilliant.'”

“The Beatles Recording Sessions” states: “They did it so well that few people, even today, know exactly where the edit it. 'That's funny,' says George Martin, 'I can hear it every time. It sticks out like a sore thumb to me!'” With this engineering session ending at 11:30 pm, it took a total of four-and-a-half hours to perform this masterful edit.

Two weeks later, on December 29th, 1966, the same engineering team assembled in the control room of EMI Studio Three to make a tape copy of the mono mix of “Strawberry Fields Forever” (labeling it “remix mono 13”) for the North American market. This, as well as creating a mono mix of “When I'm Sixty-Four,” took them from 2:30 to 4:45 pm to perform. Afterwards, they immediately tackled creating the first stereo mix of “Strawberry Fields,” working hard to mimic what they accomplished with the mono mix. While it took them four-and-a-half hours to create the mono mix, they got this done in less than an hour (4:45 to 5:40 pm) since they now knew what they were doing.

They created a stereo mix from the slower version of the song (“Take 7”) and a stereo mix of the faster version (“Take 26”). They then attempted to edit them together, which they called “remix 3,” but thought it might be able to be improved upon. A second stereo mix of the faster version was then done, and then they worked at editing together the stereo mix of the slower version with the new stereo mix of the faster version, calling this “remix 5.” In the end, it was decided that their first attempt, “remix 3,” was the better one. An interesting effect was made on this stereo mix in order to distract the listener from the edit between the two versions of the song, this being that the cello and trumpet track (featuring Greg Bowen) was panned quickly from left to right and then stays there for the rest of the song.

Two more tape copies of the mono versions of the song were made by the same engineering team in EMI Studio Two; one on December 30th, 1966 (between 7 and 8 pm) and the other on January 2nd, 1967 (between 2:30 and 4 pm). The intention of both of these tape copies were for Capitol Records in the US.

Towards the end of 1967, management decided that “Strawberry Fields Forever” would be featured on a US album “Magical Mystery Tour.” Since a stereo version already existed, all they needed to do was make a tape copy of stereo “remix 3” to give to Capitol Records in the states. This was done by the engineering team of Martin, Emerick and 2nd engineer Graham Kirkby on November 7th, 1967 in the control room of EMI Studio Two, along with many other songs that would appear on this album.

On June 6th, 1968, John and Paul did touch on "Strawberry Fields Forever" in EMI Studio Two, but not in the conventional way. During the recording of Ringo's "Don't Pass Me By," radio personality Kenny Everett stopped by to interview the group for his BBC Radio 1 series "The Kenny Everett Show.” Silliness ensued throughout the interview and, at one point Everett requested John and Paul, "Give us a rousing chorus of 'Strawberry Fields Forever' in jazz tempo.” With John humorously scat singing, snapping his fingers and slapping his knees, Paul sings the chorus in his best-improvised lounge voice, not unlike what is heard on their song "You Know My Name (Look Up The Number).” Obviously, this silly version never saw the light of day but is good for a laugh.

Also, on January 27th, 1969 during the final rehearsals at Apple Studios for what became the "Let It Be" album and film, Paul started off the session singing lead vocals on a brief version of "Strawberry Fields Forever.” This, of course, never saw the light of day.

A further stereo mix of the song was made nearly four years later, on October 26th, 1971, at George Martin's AIR Studios in London. Producer George Martin went back to the master tapes and started from scratch, creating stereo mixes of both the slower and faster versions of the song and then editing them together. Some of the noteworthy differences include more vibrant percussion quality, the panning from left to right of the swaramandala as heard at the end of the second and third choruses, and the slightly longer fade out at the end of the song (so you can actually hear “cranberry sauce” repeated twice instead of once in the previously released versions). John can also be heard quietly counting down the bars of the song during these quiet sections. The cello and trumpet track, however, just comes in on the right channel this time around just after the main edit, the panning detail probably forgotten by George Martin in the making of this new stereo mix. Nonetheless, this mix is superior to the original stereo mix in many ways and, while it had only been available on German pressings of the “Magical Mystery Tour” album for many years, has become the standard version in subsequent CD releases from 1987 onward.

Sometime in 1995, Martin and Emerick reunited to create new mixes of the slower, faster and demo versions of the song, as detailed above, for the “Anthology 2” album. Also, George Martin and his son Giles revisited all these master tapes sometime between 2004 and 2006 to create a new version of the song for the 2006 released album "Love."

Sometime in 2015, Giles Martin was commissioned to create another new stereo mix of "Strawberry Fields Forever" to pair up with the Beatles film of the song for the DVD and Blu-ray box set entitled "Beatles 1+.” Giles and Sam Okell created this excellent stereo mix in Abbey Road Studios, the result being a dynamic mix using the highly sophisticated technological advances of the time, spanning the elements of the recording with less drastic separation. The length of the song is still extended to include two vocalizations of "cranberry sauce," which is good. And while the swaramandala is still panned from the left to right channel before the final two verses, Giles was a little late in panning the instrument up during its appearance towards the end of the song. Otherwise, it's a breathtaking stereo mix.

The new stereo mix described above eventually got released as part of the 50th Anniversary "Sgt. Pepper" album in various editions. Giles Martin also saw fit to create mixes for takes 1, 4, 7 and 26 for inclusion on various editions as well.

Despite the highly elaborate production of the song, it has a quite simple structure. Apart from an inventive introduction and a high-energy rambling conclusion, it consists of 'chorus/ verse/ chorus/ verse/ chorus/ verse/ chorus' (or abababa). The song has a standard 4/4-time signature but, as usual for Lennon, this will vary periodically as described below.

Paul's distinctive Mellotron introduction, which is a shortened version of what he will be playing in the first verse, is played without any accompaniment and is four measures long, the first three being in 4/4 time and the fourth measure being in 2/4 time. The ten-measure chorus begins with a chord played on bass guitar as the downbeat, followed by John's double-tracked vocal as the Mellotron holds out a single note and the bass chord rings out. Ringo's first introductory drum fill comes in at the beginning of the second measure as George's sliding guitar enters on the three beat of the measure.

George's guitar slide lands on the downbeat of the third measure along with Ringo's cymbal crash, the entrance of Paul's bass guitar, John's finger-picking rhythm guitar and George's maracas from the rhythm track. Paul's Mellotron holds out chords for measures three through six but then changes to chopped chords in measures seven and eight. As George's sliding chord is held out in measures three and four, he plays a Morse code-like beat on his guitar neck, probably by tapping a string on the fretboard in a rhythmic pattern. Measure seven changes time signature to 2/4 during the words “nothing to get,” but then immediately changes back to 4/4 for measure eight (“hung about”). Then the ninth measure changes to 6/8 time while John sings triplets with the lyrics “strawberry fields for-,” this being accompanied by John's chord strumming rhythm guitar, Paul's Mellotron chords and overdubbed bass notes and George's maraca accents on the 1-2-3-5-6 beats of the measure. The tenth and final measure of the chorus returns to 4/4 time once again and consists of John singing “-ever” while the Mellotron holds out a single low note, John's final rhythm guitar chord rings out, and Paul's bass note adds a low end to the sound. Ringo stops drumming altogether for the last two measures of the chorus.

Each of the three verses is a standard eight-measures long and remains in 4/4 time throughout. The first measure of the first verse begins with John's single-tracked vocals singing “living is easy...” while Paul repeats his Mellotron introduction phrases and George plays a steady maraca rhythm. Ringo adds another introductory drum fill in the second measure, while the full band arrangement is resumed in the third measure and remains as such throughout the rest of the verse, this consisting of John's rhythm guitar, Paul's bass and Ringo's drums. Paul holds out Mellotron chords throughout except for measure six where he returns to playing quarter-note chops during John's lyric “-one, but it all works out.” Another added element is Ringo's drum fill at the end of measure four, his third for the song so far. John sings single-tracked throughout the verse as he does with every verse of the released version, all choruses featuring double-tracked vocals.

The second chorus then proceeds which is primarily the same structurally (except for it being eleven-measures long instead of ten). However, since the transition between the slower version and the faster version happens here, the instrumentation and arrangement could hardly be any more different. The first measure consists of John's double-tracked vocals accompanied by Paul's single-note Mellotron alone. The second measure begins yet another introductory drum fill by Ringo which is cut off midstream on the third beat of the measure at the lyric “going to...” Ringo completes this drum fill with the one he performed at this point in the faster version of the song, a difference in drum tone being detected because of this recording using a substitute producer/engineer as well as the track being slowed down substantially to match up the tempo and key of the song. John's vocals also noticeably sound eerily lower in tone at this point, which creates a menacing feel to what mind-altering experience one may have in this mysterious “Strawberry Fields” place!

Other elements that appear here include George's falling guitar chord from the second to the third measure and Paul holding out a single Mellotron note in the third and fourth measure. Also, the cellos play a low foreboding score by George Martin while Paul comes in on timpani, George Harrison on bongos, Mal Evans on tambourine and Ringo on drums who now is even more generous with drum fills. Also adding to the percussive din is the backward drumming as produced by Dave Harries on December 8th, this being heard in all the remaining choruses of the recording. The trumpets appear for the first time in measures seven and eight. The climactic ninth measure displays the cellos underlying John's very British-sounding lyric “strawberry fields foreveh!” with a deep bass resonance which is held out commandingly throughout the tenth and eleventh measures of this chorus. Ringo and Mal Evans percussively accent John's final lyrics and then fall off for the remainder of the chorus. The added eleventh measure is taken up by George Harrison's falling swaramandala eighth-note melody line while the cellos still hold down the low end.

Verse two is extremely different from verse one instrumentally although it is identical structurally. There are no keyboards or guitars of any kind, the trumpets and cellos being the main instruments. John sings single tracked while the trumpets hold out a unified chord throughout. On the three beat of the first measure we hear a stray final note from George's swaramandala (on the word “think”), and then Ringo's carefully planned backwards cymbals are panned in by the end of the second measure, which becomes louder as the verse continues. On the third beat of the fourth measure, the cellos enter the picture holding out harmonized notes through the fifth and sixth measures. The cellos then change to eighth notes for the seventh and eighth measures while a crashed cymbal dissolves at the fourth beat of the eighth measure.

The third chorus then begins with the cellos holding out their low notes as a pad for John's double-tracked vocals. George's falling guitar, and swaramandala playing, Paul's single note Mellotron playing, Ringo's drums (frontwards and backwards) and the heavy percussion are performed quite similarly to what was heard in the second chorus, but George Martin's score for the cellos and trumpets have become more elaborate this time around.

The third verse, while similar to the second, has some noticeable differences as well. The trumpets are the first to appear as a backdrop this time, playing a quarter-note pattern for the first three measures. They stop in the fourth measure to allow the cellos to appear playing quarter-notes for the second half of that measure, but then play a triplet pattern for the fifth measure and the first half of the sixth measure, going back to quarter-notes for the second half of that measure. The trumpets come back in playing half-notes for the seventh and eighth measures while the cellos play eighth-notes throughout the seventh and eighth measures, changing to sixteenth-notes on the final beat of the eighth measure. Noteworthy also is Ringo's backwards cymbals which change from quarter-notes to sixteenth-notes from the sixth measure until the verse completes.

The fourth and final chorus then commences, this one being fifteen-measures long. All of the elements of the previous two choruses (except the swaramandala) are kept intact, the cello and trumpet score being changed up a little once again. The first vocal line this time, however, is sung in harmony, the only harmony singing in this otherwise elaborate arrangement. The additional measures for this chorus are as follows: The final phrase “strawberry fields forever” is repeated three times and the eleventh surmandal measure is omitted, which results in the eleventh measure now being in 6/8 time to accommodate John's repeating the song's title a second time. The twelfth measure is in 3/4 time as a space-keeper, while the thirteenth measure is also in 6/8 time for the third repeat of the song's title. Two measures of 4/4 end this chorus, the second featuring a lead guitar figure from Paul as a segue into the meandering conclusion of the song. The cello and trumpet score, Ringo's drum fills and the assorted percussion follow along as the ending pattern of this chorus unfolds.

Now the song jumps into the psychedelic twenty-seven measure conclusion. The heavy percussion and drums, which were double-tracked, propel these measures while the other elements appear to be added in an arbitrary fashion. Paul begins by plunking quarter-note chords on a piano, which he continues to do until the song fades. George Martin had the cellos play a simple score for measures one through four and then measure six. Paul plays a simple guitar passage in measure five, while George Harrison reprises his swaramandala in measures seven through twelve, the instrument also being detected in measures three and five among the cellos. During these measures, the song begins to fade away, fooling the listener into thinking the song is over. In these quiet moments, in measures twelve through fourteen, we start to hear John's indistinguishable vocal hi-jinks, which carry on through to the end of the recording.

Upon examination (especially of the bootleg recordings), the exactness of the downbeat to the song becomes somewhat obscured, creating a disorienting feeling, which may have influenced George Martin to lower the volume here to hide the sloppiness. During this sloppiness, in measure fifteen, is the first appearance of the above mentioned “looped flutes” Mellotron from Paul (or possibly George Martin or John), which signals the song to be faded up once again, the highest volume being reached with some quarter- note trumpet blasts in measures eighteen through twenty. The Mellotron dissipated with the appearance of the trumpets but then reappears for measures twenty-one through twenty-three. As the Mellotron disappears, the song begins to fade again while John mutters “cranberry sauce” for the first time in measure twenty-four and then again in measure twenty-six (as heard in some versions of the recording). As Paul still fiddles on the piano and the drums/percussion finally wind down, the history-changing recording finally fades from view.

After the engineering team's excellent editing and tape manipulations, John's lead vocals never sounded any more menacing or hypnotic, which adds perfectly to the song's lyrical mystery. His competent finger-picking electric guitar work in the first segment is proof of his adeptness with the instrument if anyone ever doubts his ability as a guitarist. Paul, as usual, stirred many ladles in this pot with his masterful Mellotron playing, as well as his contributions on bass, piano, lead guitar, and timpani. Ringo shines brightly with his double-tracked drumming, flamboyant fills, and strategic backwards cymbal work. George may be thought to have taken a back seat on this song, but his contributions here include slide guitar, swaramandala, bongos and even maracas, and all done well.

As far as George Martin's role, he explains: “In John's case, his ideas weren't all that concise, so I had to try to realize what he wanted and how to effect it, and I would do this either by means of an orchestra or sound effects or a combination of both. This role was an interesting one because it presented many challenges for me. I would come up to new problems every day because the songs themselves presented those problems. The songs in the early days were straightforward, and you couldn't play around with them too much. Here we are building sound pictures.” George Martin, along with Geoff Emerick, established the knack for transforming John's ideas into masterpieces, evidenced best in “Strawberry Fields Forever.”

Please feel free to leave any comments or corrections and share these articles plus the blog's website with your friends, especially Beatles’ fans. You and they might also enjoy knowing more about my Love Songs CD and my novel, BEATLEMANIAC. Just click on the “My Shop” tab near the top of this page for full details.

Join me soon for the Unfolding Process of "PENNY LANE."